Home Navigating Thermal Challenges in Fuel Cell EVs with New Innovations

Thermal management is a critical barrier to the widespread commercialization of Fuel Cell Electric Vehicles (FCEVs). While secondary challenges like fuel cell system costs, hydrogen distribution, durability, and public education persist, effective thermal management is paramount for FCEVs to succeed. Some of the key challenges that FCEVs are facing include excessive heat generation, radiator size and weight, temperature control etc. This article provides a comprehensive analysis into how these challenges can be overcome by adopting recent advancements like high-temperature fuel cells, advanced heat exchangers, optimized control strategies, innovative materials, phase-change cooling, etc.

Challenges in Thermal Management of FCEVs

With the surge in investments from startups and automotive giants into the R&D of Fuel Cell Electric Vehicles (FCEVs), new challenges are emerging daily. While secondary hurdles like fuel cell system costs, hydrogen distribution, durability, and public education persist, the most critical challenge remains thermal management. Effective thermal management is pivotal and could be the key barrier to the widespread commercialization of FCEVs, underscoring its importance in the path to sustainable transportation. This can be better understood with the help of the following mathematical formulas and equations.

The cooling performance of the radiator can be represented through a thermodynamic equation of heat flow:

Heat flow, Q = k*A*Dt

Where, K = thermal conductivity coefficient, A – Area of radiator, Dt = Radiator Inlet temp – ambient temp

Q

FutureBridge_thermodynamics in Fuel cells

  • For ICE (Internal Combustion Engine)

It can run up to 120°C, Ambient Temp = 40°C Dt= 120-40 = 80°C (Dt = Engine Temperature – Ambient Temperature)

The Radiator has certain dimensions, surface area and K factor.

Q

FutureBridge_ICE (Internal Combustion Engine)

  • For BEV (Battery Electric Vehicle)

It can run up to 80°C, Ambient Temp = 40°C

Dt= 80-40 = 40°C

Electric drivetrains operate at relatively low temperatures, which significantly reduces cooling demands. Under similar conditions, the cooling performance with the same radiator is only half that of a combustion drivetrain. Additionally, due to the high efficiency of electric drivetrains, EVs can utilize smaller radiators compared to their combustion engine counterparts, optimizing space and energy use without compromising performance. But for fuel cell drivetrains, this can become a problem.

Q

FutureBridge_BEV (Battery Electric Vehicle)

  • For FCEV (Fuel Cell Electric Vehicle)

It can run up to 80°C, Ambient Temp = 40°C

Dt= 80-40 = 40°C

In addition to the electric drivetrain, FCEVs incorporate a fuel cell with around 50% efficiency to power the vehicle. From a thermodynamics standpoint, this lower efficiency results in significantly more waste heat, necessitating a much greater cooling capacity. However, since the operating temperatures of FCEVs are nearly identical to those of battery electric vehicles (BEVs), this translates to a need for larger radiators in FCEVs compared to BEVs to effectively manage the excess heat.

Q

FutureBridge_For FCEV (Fuel Cell Electric Vehicle)

Now, coming to efficiencies of ICE, BEV, & FCEV 

Efficiency of ICE 

It’s widely recognized that in today’s combustion engines, only about 30 to 35 percent of the fuel’s input power is converted into energy to propel the vehicle forward. Approximately one-third of the energy is lost as heat in the cooling system, while the remaining third exits the engine through the exhaust.  

Q

FutureBridge_Efficiency of ICE

So, if 20kW is required from a combustion engine to drive a car forward, 60kW is needed to input through fuel. 20kW would be the power from the engine, 20kW would have to be cooled by the cooling system and 20kW would leave the car through the exhaust.

Efficiency of BEV

In the case of electric cars, it can be assumed that the overall efficiency is 80% – from the battery to the motor shaft including motors and inverters having individual efficiencies of ~93%.

Q

FutureBridge_Efficiency of BEV

Efficiency of FCEV

Now, let’s examine the fuel cell vehicle. Like battery electric vehicles (BEVs), FCEVs share the same electric drivetrain but also incorporate a fuel cell. Assuming the fuel cell operates at a high efficiency of 60%, and with an estimated 90% efficiency for charging the battery and similar efficiencies for the other electric components, the overall efficiency from the fuel cell to the motor shaft is about 45%. Additionally, FCEVs feature a boost function, where the battery is bypassed, allowing the fuel cell to directly power the electric motor, resulting in an efficiency of around 50%

Q

FutureBridge_Efficiency of FCEV

Now, consider an FCEV that requires 20 kW to drive the car; it would need 45 kW from the system, with 25 kW needing to be dissipated through the cooling system. In FCEVs, all components are water-cooled, meaning the heat remains within the vehicle and must be managed by the cooling system. This results in a significantly higher cooling demand compared to an internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicle. In fact, to compensate for the lower temperature difference, the radiator size in an FCEV needs to be doubled. Consequently, a fuel cell vehicle requires 2.5 times more cooling capacity than an ICE vehicle for the same task, whereas a battery electric vehicle (BEV) only requires half the cooling.

Q

FutureBridge_Fuel cell comparative table

Even if it is assumed that boost function is used for a constant speed, still nearly twice as much cooling compared to the ICE car would be needed.

Effective strategies to optimize cooling and boost FCEV performance

  • Increasing the operating temperature of energy cells

 Los Alamos researchers created a new polymer electrolyte for high-temperature fuel cells, combining phosphonated polymer and perfluorosulfonic acid. It achieved 60% higher power density than phosphoric acid cells, solving overheating issues in medium and heavy-duty applications like trucks and buses.

  • Choosing effective designs like microchannel heat exchangers, plate- and- frame heat exchangers, and helical heat exchangers
    • ZeroAvia developed advanced hydrogen-electric aircraft tech, including a pressurized HTPEM system and innovative coatings for aluminum bipolar plates.
    • Alfa Laval created ALFANOVA, an all-stainless steel plate heat exchanger for demanding gas-to-liquid operations, using patented ALFAFUSION technology.
    • Researchers are also exploring 3D printing to create more efficient and sustainable heat exchangers with complex geometries such as fins and microchannel, potentially outperforming traditional manufacturing methods.
  • Optimizing the inflow rates and distribution, like control strategies similar as model- based control to optimize the inflow rate and inflow distribution.

South Korean researchers optimized heat exchangers using genetic algorithms, reducing size and weight while improving performance. They considered vehicle driving cycles for dynamic analysis. Separately, a joint study by Northumbria and Huazhong Universities developed a comprehensive hybrid vehicle model, including a 30kW PEMFC stack. They successfully maintained stack temperature at 350K under real driving conditions, with constant lower inlet cooling water temperature (340K) improving control.

  • Using advanced materials with better thermal conductivity, such as ceramics or composites, to create heat exchangers with higher thermal conductivity and lower thermal expansion.

Researchers explored methods to enhance heat dissipation in PEMFC thermal management systems. They tested three nanofluids—Al2O3, SiO2, and ZnO—as cooling media due to their high electrical and thermal conductivity. All nanofluids improved heat transfer capacity, with Al2O3 nanofluid showing the best overall performance, addressing the high heat issue in PEMFC operation.

  • Using advanced cooling ways like liquid cooling or phase- change cooling.

A new thermal management system for fuel cell vehicles addresses heat overload issues caused by increasing fuel cell stack power. The system uses a heat-peak controller—a thermal accumulator filled with phase-change material—that interacts with both coolant and air conditioning refrigerant. It temporarily stores excess heat during peak periods, then transfers it to the refrigerant for removal via the condenser when the peak subsides.

  • Limiting the maximum power: Limiting fuel cell vehicle power to around 150kW eliminates the need for oversized radiators. This power threshold allows for adequate cooling using standard-sized radiators, avoiding the drag penalties associated with larger cooling systems required for higher power outputs.

Recent Updates

Advancements in thermal management for fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEVs) are driving improvements in efficiency, durability, and overall performance. For instance, Daniel Murphy’s recent project explored ways to enhance the efficiency and reduce emissions of Proton Exchange Membrane Fuel Cells (PEM FC) in heavy-duty electric vehicles, focusing on developing a ruggedized thermal management system (TMS) with a compact, high-temperature radiator designed for low ΔT operation.

Meanwhile, Prof. Prakash C. Ghosh and Nadiya Philip from IIT Bombay introduced a novel method for optimizing the weight and size of FCEV components, boosting vehicle efficiency and accelerating commercialization.

The patent landscape in FCEV thermal management is also rapidly evolving, with China, the USA, and Germany leading in 2024. Notably, Daimler’s February 2024 patent (DE102022132851B3) details a method for estimating the thermal output of a vehicle’s cooling system based on current driving conditions and environmental factors. Additionally, Robert Bosch’s January 2024 patent (DE102022207195A1) addresses load reduction during high-temperature operation, implementing gradual load reduction to prevent excessive wear on fuel cells by managing cooling more effectively.

Conclusion and Futuristic Perspectives

As of now the thermal management system poses various challenges that need to be addressed to ensure safe and efficient operation. These include:

  • Heat Management
  • Cold Start
  • Durability
  • Reliability
  • The most prominent one – the Size and weight of the Radiator.

Adopting advanced strategies can address thermal management challenges in FCEVs. The push for next-generation vehicles—hybrids, plug-in hybrids, FCEVs, and BEVs—continues to spur innovation in this area. Innovators are exploring thermal management techniques for fuel cell plug-in hybrids in low-temperature environments. Advances in battery thermal management, such as hydrogen storage in metal hydrides, show promise for fuel cell hybrids.

Innovative thermal management solutions will be crucial for new powertrains, especially in long-haul heavy-duty vehicles. Ongoing research into EV thermal management is expected to yield new insights and strategies applicable to FCEVs.

Our foresight finds the future of thermal management in FCEVs promising, with significant potential for improvement across its efficiency, performance, and sustainability. By addressing the existing challenges and capitalizing on emerging technologies, the industry can pave the way for the widespread adoption of FCEVs.

Engage with our experts for guidance on cutting-edge thermal management solutions in FCEVs, driving efficiency, performance, and sustainability in next-gen vehicles.

 

Need a thought partner?

Share your focus area or question to engage with our Analysts through the Business Objectives service.

Submit My Business Objective

Our Clients

Our long-standing clients include some of the worlds leading brands and forward-thinking corporations.